A bank yard is not a compacted yard. Check the shrink and swell factor before you bid.
A cut/fill takeoff tells you how many cubic yards sit in the ground, in place. That number is useful. It is not, by itself, the volume you will haul, or the volume that will land in the fill after compaction. Almost all materials change volume when they move from cut to truck to embankment. If you treat a bank cubic yard as if it were already a compacted cubic yard, import, export, truck counts and haul time all drift — and the miss shows up after award.
Federal Highway Administration guidance for Federal Lands highway design is direct on this point. Roadway excavation is typically measured in the original, undisturbed position, and the specifications must clearly state the place and method of measurement, because almost all materials change volume in their movement from cut to fill.
The same FHWA Earthwork Design page walks through the three states estimators actually price:
Excavated solid rock usually goes the other way. Placed in a fill, it typically occupies a larger volume than it did in place. That change is the swell. FHWA notes that when the voids in a rock embankment become filled with earth or other fine material, the volume in the fill will just about equal the combined volumes in the two source locations.
FHWA Federal Lands’ Earthwork Representation Guide uses the same language estimators use on a cut/fill report: shrink/swell factors adjust quantities from the bank (BCY) state to the compacted (CCY) state, and the factors to use are the ones recommended in the geotechnical report. Swell factors (values greater than one) are typically associated with rocky materials. Shrink factors (values less than one) are typically associated with clayey or granular materials.
FHWA publishes a table of shrinkage and swell values that “may be used for estimating purposes prior to obtaining the project specific information from the Geotechnical Unit.” The same page is explicit about the limits of that table: mass densities are subject to adjustment, a negative swell number represents shrinkage, and the factors are subject to substantial variation. The design, it says, should use data furnished by the geotechnical unit, and when they are available, actual field shrink and swell factors for like material used on adjoining projects.
For ranges, FHWA describes — not prescribes — the following, always dependent on the material and the work:
Those are FHWA’s published ranges for design context. They are not a substitute for the factor in your geotechnical report or the measurement rules in your specification. Shrink, as FHWA notes, can also include slight waste in transport, material that escapes beyond the toe of slopes, and the effect of slightly overbuilt embankments. Settlement of the ground under a new fill can contribute to an apparent shrink, but shrink should not be confused with subsidence of a weak foundation.
If the report is silent, or the spec measures excavation and embankment in different positions (bank versus compacted), that is a bid question, not a gap to fill with a favorite percentage.
Once the factor is wrong, several cost centers move at once.
Import and export. If compacted fill takes more bank cubic yards than a 1:1 takeoff assumed, the job can go from “balanced” to short, and you have borrow and haul you did not price. If the material shrinks less than you assumed, or swells, you can end up with waste, a dump site and trucking you did not carry. The takeoff surfaces do not make that adjustment by themselves.
Haul and production. Loose volume is what actually sits in the truck. Understating swell in the haul unit changes cycle times, truck counts and the time on the schedule to move the same bank quantity.
Place of measurement. If the specification measures excavation in the bank and embankment in the compacted position, the shrink/swell factor is how those two numbers meet. If both are measured in the same position, the factor still matters for equipment, moisture and whether on-site material will actually build the fill you planned.
Balance points. FHWA’s Earthwork Design guidance treats shrink and swell as part of balancing cut and fill, including the effect of subexcavation and reserved topsoil. A mass diagram built on unadjusted bank volumes will not match the work you have to perform.
Before you lock import, export and haul:
3 sets of eyes check every project before it reaches your desk.
Complete Bid Proposals. Field Knowledge. Ongoing Support.
If you want another look at the geotech and the grading plan before you bid, send us your plans.
A cut/fill number is only as good as the sheets behind it. Most excavation estimators open the grading plan, glance at the contours, and move on. The misses that blow a bid usually sit in three places people skim: where existing and proposed grades fight each other, where spot elevations and finished floors fight the slopes, and where the margin notes say something the contours don't.
We see the same pattern across excavation bids in 40+ states: solid software output, weak sheet reading. The fix is a short desk check — not another assumption.
Pricing a job now? Send us your plans.
The design grades tell you where the dirt is supposed to end up. The existing contours tell you what is already there. Where those two fight — steep daylight lines, unexplained fill pockets, a pad that sits far above or below the existing surface — your dig and fill story changes.
Check: Trace existing and proposed through the pad, parking and drive areas. Mark every place the difference is larger than the surrounding slope can explain. Those marks are your first cut/fill questions, not afterthoughts.
A finished floor elevation that looks fine in a schedule can still fight the grades around it. When the FFE, the pad elevation and the surrounding slopes don't agree, you inherit undercut, import, retaining or rework you may not have priced.
Check: Pull every spot elevation and FFE that touches the work. Compare each one to the nearest contours and to the sections. If the sheet needs a wall, a bench or a thicker section to make the number work, put it on the clarification list before you lock unit costs.
Undercut, match existing, temporary stockpile, phase lines, "see civil detail," and "verify in field" notes live in the margins and keynotes. If you only read the contour ballet, you miss the instructions that change stripping, haul and sequencing.
Check: Read the legend, the general notes and every clouded callout on the grading sheets. Copy anything that changes quantity or production onto a one-page checklist next to your takeoff.
Before you trust the software total:
That list will not catch every miss. It catches the ones that show up most often when a bid goes sideways after award.
With Paydirt, 3 sets of eyes check every project before it reaches your desk — including a pass that is specifically about reading the grading sheets, not just running the model.
Contours, spot elevations, margin notes. Open all three before you lock the number.
Send us your plans through our work order request form (https://paydirtsupport.com/work-order-request-form/), or call 843-900-1002.
Paydirt: Complete Bid Proposals. Field Knowledge. Ongoing Support.
A takeoff tells you how much dirt. Production costing tells you what it costs to move it. Two contractors can start with the same quantities and end up with very different bids, because the price depends on how the work actually gets done: which machines, how many trucks, how far the haul, how fast the crew can produce. Here’s how to turn quantities into a bid you can win. Pricing a job now? Send us your plans.
Your takeoff gives you cut, fill, stripping, undercut and import or export. Those numbers matter, but a cubic yard of excavation on one site can cost far more than on another. Access, soils, haul distance and phasing all change the cost of the same yard. Treat the takeoff as the foundation of the estimate, not the estimate itself.
That’s why a bid built by multiplying quantities by a single unit price can miss in both directions. Price too high and you lose the job. Price too low and you win a job that loses money. The goal of excavation production costing is to price the work the way it will actually be built on this site.
Start with where the dirt goes. A balanced site that moves material a short distance is a very different job from one that needs import from offsite or export to a dump. Use the cut and fill balance to plan the mass haul: where you cut, where you fill, and how far material travels. Haul distance drives your fleet size and cycle times, so it shapes the whole production estimate.
Look at haul roads too. Steep grades, soft ground and long routes around obstacles slow trucks down and add cost even when the straight-line distance is short.
The right spread depends on the work. Mass excavation, fine grading, trenching and loading trucks all call for different machines. Match equipment to the quantities and the site conditions, then price each piece for the time it will actually be on the job. Oversizing the spread costs money every hour. Undersizing it slows production and stretches the schedule.
Think about the whole spread working together. Excavators, dozers, compactors and trucks need to be balanced, so one machine isn’t sitting idle waiting on another. Where the job uses 3D GPS machine control, factor in the model and the setup so the field crew can grade to design with fewer stakes and less rework.
Production rates turn quantities into hours. Estimate how many yards per hour each operation can realistically produce on this site, then size the crew and the fleet to match. Be honest about the conditions: tight access, wet soils or a busy site will slow things down. A production estimate built on realistic rates is what separates a bid that makes money from one that only looks competitive.
Don’t forget the time that isn’t moving dirt: mobilization, setup, weather, testing and waiting on other trades. Those hours still cost money, and they belong in the estimate.
The geotech report changes how material digs, loads and places. Rock, clay, saturated soils and unsuitable material each affect production, equipment choice and compaction effort. Read the boring logs and recommendations, and build their effects into your rates instead of assuming average conditions.
How the job is sequenced affects cost. Phased construction, limited access points, work around existing buildings or traffic, and erosion control requirements can all force extra moves, smaller equipment or more mobilizations. Walk through the phasing plan and price the job the way it will really be built.
Trucking and disposal can be one of the biggest lines in an excavation bid. Price the real cost of hauling: the distance, the number of trucks, dump fees and the cost of approved fill if you need it. Confirm local sources and sites before bid day so the numbers hold up.
Topsoil is part of this too. Decide whether it is stockpiled on site and respread, or hauled off, and price the handling either way.
Every site has unknowns. Unsuitable soils, groundwater, rock and plan conflicts can all change the cost after award. Identify the risks you can see, decide how to price them, and spell out what’s included and excluded in your clarifications. A clear proposal protects your margin and shows the owner you understand the job.
Bring it together: quantities from the takeoff, production rates, equipment, crew, haul, risk and clarifications, organized into a complete bid proposal. Paydirt builds that package for excavation and civil contractors, with US-based project management and QC on every estimate, backed by our dedicated production team, and 3 sets of eyes on every project before it reaches your desk.
When you review an estimate before bid day, you should be able to see the quantities it started from, the production rates it assumes, the equipment and crew it carries, how the haul is priced, and the risks it covers or excludes. If you can’t trace a number back to those pieces, it’s hard to defend on bid day or manage after award.
A takeoff number tells you what’s on the plans. A production estimate tells you what it will take to build it. That’s the difference between a number and a bid you can win.
Send us your plans through our work order request form (https://paydirtsupport.com/work-order-request-form/), or call 843-900-1002.
Paydirt: Complete Bid Proposals. Field Knowledge. Ongoing Support.
Winning work in a new state can grow your business fast, but the plans, specs and soils don’t always read the way they do at home. We work with excavation and civil contractors in 40+ states, and some of our top states are North Carolina, Georgia, South Carolina, Ohio, Tennessee, Indiana, Texas, Pennsylvania, Kentucky, Colorado and Washington. Every one of those markets has its own habits. Here’s what we check when a job crosses a state line. Bidding one now? Send us your plans.
Before you price a single yard, find out which specs govern the job. Many site projects lean on the state DOT’s standard specifications for things like embankment, subgrade preparation, aggregate base and compaction testing, even when the owner is private. The section numbers, the testing frequency and the acceptance criteria are not the same from one state to the next. Read the general notes on the cover sheet and the spec book reference, then pull the sections that touch your scope. A bid built on your home state’s standard can miss a requirement that changes how you place and test material.
Soil types, groundwater and bearing notes shift from region to region. Clay that behaves one way in one market can be a very different problem a few states over, and a site with a shallow water table changes how you dig, dewater and haul. Read the full geotechnical report, not just the summary page. Look at the boring logs, the groundwater readings and the recommendations for subgrade, fill placement and undercut. Those pages drive your excavation quantities and your production assumptions.
How the dirt behaves changes the balance. Material that bulks when you dig it or compacts tighter when you place it will move your import and export numbers, sometimes enough to turn a balanced site into a haul job. Don’t carry a shrink or swell factor over from your last job in another state. Check whether the geotech report gives factors for the site, note them on your takeoff, and flag the assumption in your bid if the report is silent.
Stripping depth is one of the easiest places to lose money on an out-of-state job. Confirm what the plans and specs call for instead of assuming your home-state habit. Look for a stripping depth in the geotech report, the grading notes or the spec, and check whether topsoil gets stockpiled and respread or hauled off. A small change in depth across a large site adds up to a real quantity of material to move.
Look for where the geotech flags soft or unsuitable soils and how it’s handled. Some reports call out specific areas for undercut and replacement. Others leave it to field decisions during construction. Either way, your bid needs to show how you treat it: a quantity carried in the base bid, a unit price, or a clear clarification. On a new market, that line item protects you from soils you haven’t worked before.
State and local erosion control and stormwater requirements change what goes into the bid. Permit conditions, inspection requirements, inlet protection, silt fence, sediment basins and stabilization timelines vary by state and sometimes by county. Read the erosion control sheets and the permit notes carefully, and make sure the phasing they require lines up with how you plan to run the excavation.
Haul routes, dump sites and borrow sources are new when you’re new to the area. You may not know where the nearest place to take spoils is, what it charges, or where to get approved fill. Those answers drive trucking costs as much as the quantities do. Use the cut and fill balance from your takeoff to decide early whether the job is an import job, an export job or close to balanced, then price the haul with real local options.
Read every addendum. Owners and engineers in each market do things their own way, from how they issue revisions to what they expect in a bid form. A late addendum can change grades, add a sheet or swap a spec section. Check that your takeoff is built on the latest revision of every sheet, and note the addenda you priced in your proposal.
The specs and soils change from state to state, but your quantities shouldn’t depend on where the job is. With Paydirt, you get US-based project management and QC on every estimate, backed by our dedicated production team. 3 sets of eyes check every project before it reaches your desk, so the numbers you carry into a new market are checked the same way as the ones you bid at home.
Quantities are the start, not the finish. Paydirt turns the numbers into a complete bid proposal you can submit with confidence: excavation takeoffs, cut and fill, utility quantities, production estimates and 3D GPS machine control models when the job calls for them. Wherever the job is, the process is the same. Send us your plans.
A new state is a chance to grow, and the right prep keeps it from becoming a costly lesson. Check the specs, read the geotech report, confirm stripping and undercut, price the haul with local options and read every addendum.
Send us your plans through our work order request form (https://paydirtsupport.com/work-order-request-form/), or call 843-900-1002.
Paydirt: Complete Bid Proposals. Field Knowledge. Ongoing Support.
